NY appeals court overturns Trump's civil fraud penalty

NY appeals court overturns Trump’s civil fraud penalty

A New York appeals court has tossed out a $454 million civil fraud verdict against Donald Trump and his family business over charges he broke state laws by inflating the values on his properties.

In Thursday’s ruling, the First Judicial Department of the New York State Appellate Division kept in place non-monetary penalties imposed by a lower court on now-President Trump and his company, but said the more than half-billion-dollar fine imposed as part of the guilty verdict is “excessive” and violates the Eighth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.

The court’s 323-page ruling, which included several opinions, shows that the five-member panel was deeply divided over Trump’s appeal. Some judges said they were in favor of upholding the fraud ruling but dismissing the fines, others in favor of ordering a new trial, and at least one who would have dismissed the case entirely.

“While the injunctive relief ordered by the court is well crafted to curb defendants’ business culture, the court’s disgorgement order, which directs that defendants pay nearly half a billion dollars to the State of New York, is an excessive fine that violates the Eighth Amendment of the United States Constitution,” two of the judges, Dianne Renwick and Peter Moulton, wrote in one opinion.

A lawsuit against Trump and his company by Democratic New York State Attorney General Letitia James alleged that Trump overvalued his properties on financial statements between 2014 and 2021 by hundreds of millions of dollars, which deprived the state and New York City of tax revenue.

In February 2024, Manhattan Supreme Court Judge Arthur Engoron ordered Trump and his organization to pay around $454 million in penalties after finding him liable for business fraud. With interest, the fines were expected to reach more than $500 million. At the time, Trump was running for president.

Trump praised the court for overturning an “unlawful and disgraceful” penalty in a post on social media that blasted James as a “corrupt and Incompetent Attorney General who only brought this Case in order to hurt me politically.

She is a Trump Deranged Lunatic! They made me bond the outrageous sum, which never happened before, and which cost me Millions of Dollars a month,” he posted on X. It should have never been allowed to happen, and everyone knew it! It was a Political Witch Hunt, in a business sense, the likes of which no one has ever seen before.”

Eric Trump, the president’s son and a defendant in the lawsuit, took to social media to praise the court’s ruling and criticize James for prosecuting his family.

“Total victory in the sham NY Attorney General case!!! After 5 years of hell, justice prevailed!” he wrote.

James, a Democrat first elected in 2018, has been a frequent critic of Trump and, in addition to the civil fraud trial, has filed several multistate lawsuits against the Trump administration over federal immigration policies, rollbacks in federal funding, and worker layoffs and other actions.

Earlier this month, news reports revealed that the Justice Department has subpoenaed James as part of an investigation into whether she violated Trump’s civil rights during his civil trial on fraud charges.

James said she will appeal the ruling to the state’s highest court, the Court of Appeals, and highlighted that the decision “affirmed the well-supported finding of the trial court: Donald Trump, his company, and two of his children are liable for fraud.”

“The court upheld the injunctive relief we won, limiting Donald Trump and the Trump Organization officers’ ability to do business in New York. It should not be lost to history: yet another court has ruled that the president violated the law, and that our case has merit,” James said in a statement. “We will seek appeal to the Court of Appeals and continue to protect the rights and interests of New Yorkers.”

Events

No events

Leave a Comment





Latest News Stories

WCO Board Aug 21.4

After Initial Rejection and Tense Debate, Board Reconsiders and Approves Contested DuPage Township Business

Article Summary: In a rare reversal, the Will County Board approved a special use permit for a landscaping business in a residential area of DuPage Township after the measure initially...
Meeting Briefs

Meeting Summary and Briefs: Will County Board for August 21, 2025

The Will County Board received County Executive Jennifer Bertino-Tarrant’s proposed $791 million budget for fiscal year 2026, which holds the line on the property tax levy while funding key services....
Will County Recorder Graphic.1

Will County Board Approves New Fee Schedule for Recorder of Deeds

Article Summary: The Will County Board has approved a revised fee schedule for the Recorder of Deeds office, which will take effect on October 1, 2025. The changes, based on...
WCO Board Aug 21.3

Will County Board Formally Opposes Heavier, Longer Trucks on National Roadways

Article Summary: The Will County Board unanimously passed a resolution opposing any federal legislation that would increase the size and weight limits for commercial trucks on the nation's roadways. The...
will county board meeting graphic.5

Will County Board Approves Permits for Landscaping Business and Restaurant Liquor Service in Frankfort Area

Article SummaryThe Will County Board unanimously approved three separate special use permits for businesses in the Frankfort area, allowing a landscaping operation in Green Garden Township to continue and two...
will county board meeting.6

Crete Township Community Center to Get New Digital Sign

Article Summary: The Will County Board approved a special use permit and two variances for Crete Township, allowing for the installation of a new on-premise dynamic display sign at its...
will county board meeting.6

Will County Awards $1.46 Million Contract for Kankakee Street Bridge Replacement in Manhattan Township

Article SummaryThe Will County Board has awarded a $1.46 million contract to "D" Construction, Inc. of Coal City to replace the Kankakee Street Bridge over Jackson Creek in Manhattan Township....
will county board meeting graphic.5

Board Approves Engineering Contracts for Mokena Road Widening

Article SummaryThe Will County Board approved over $1.1 million in supplemental engineering contracts to advance the ongoing 80th Avenue improvement project in Mokena. The additional funding addresses project delays and...
WCO Board Aug 21.1

Will County Executive Proposes $791 Million Budget Focused on Stability Amidst Economic Uncertainty

Article Summary: Will County Executive Jennifer Bertino-Tarrant presented a balanced $791 million budget proposal for Fiscal Year 2026 that aims to maintain services and prepare for potential economic challenges without...
Screenshot-2025-08-19-at-6.09.01-PM

Peotone School Board Rejects Mandating Live-Streaming in 4-3 Vote

Article Summary: The Peotone school board has opted against requiring its meetings to be live-streamed, finalizing a new committee policy after a 4-3 vote defeated the mandate. The decision followed...
WATCH: Detransitioner gets a second chance at medical malpractice lawsuit

WATCH: Detransitioner gets a second chance at medical malpractice lawsuit

By Carleen JohnsonThe Center Square A young woman whose detransition story has been one of the most widely covered in the nation will soon learn if a judge in North...
WATCH: CA Democrats pass congressional redistricting plan

WATCH: CA Democrats pass congressional redistricting plan

By Dave MasonThe Center Square After a day of vigorous debates punctuated by occasional applause, both houses of the California Legislature Thursday passed the three bills making up the congressional...
Pew: U.S. immigrant population declines for first time in nearly 60 years

Pew: U.S. immigrant population declines for first time in nearly 60 years

By Caroline BodaThe Center Square The U.S.’s foreign-born population shrunk this year for the first time since the 1960s, new data released Thursday from the nonpartisan Pew Research Center found....
WATCH: Illinois’ FY23 financial audit released amid criticism of tardy reports

WATCH: Illinois’ FY23 financial audit released amid criticism of tardy reports

By Greg Bishop | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – Illinois taxpayers can now look at how the state spent their money in the fiscal year that...
European Union says U.S. consumers will end up paying tariffs

European Union says U.S. consumers will end up paying tariffs

By Brett RowlandThe Center Square European Union leaders detailed the terms of a trade deal they struck with President Donald Trump on Thursday, making sure to point out who will...